Wednesday, 15 June 2011

REID CALLS ON GOVERNMENT TO SAVE THE CLYDE COASTGUARD STATION IN GREENOCK

Speaking in a House of Commons debate on the Coastguard service, Alan Reid, MP for Argyll & Bute, called on the Government to keep the threatened Clyde coastguard station open.

Mr Reid told the House of Commons that it was vitally important to keep the coastguard station and its staff who have acquired detailed local knowledge of the seas around his Argyll & Bute constituency.

Extracts from his speech follow.

“My constituency has many islands and peninsulas, which means its coastline is longer than that of France and that the Clyde coastguard station has a longer coastline than any of the coastguard stations to look after. Islands, peninsulas and sea lochs create a wide variety of currents and sea conditions, which is one reason why local knowledge is very important.”
“I also want to stress the importance of local knowledge in differentiating between different places that have the same name. On the islands and the mainland of the west of Scotland, a large number of places are called Tarbert because Tarbert means a narrow neck of land in Gaelic. It would be easy for someone not familiar with that to send the rescue vessel to the wrong place. It is also important to be able to differentiate between, for example, East Loch Tarbert and West Loch Tarbert.”

“Once the Government have had an opportunity to consider the responses to the consultation, I hope that they will recognise the unique challenges posed by the area served by the Clyde coastguard station and that they will keep it open to retain the valuable local knowledge that exists. It is important to point out that, if staff are forced to relocate to Aberdeen, as appears to be the case from the Government’s proposals, that is well over 100 miles away and many staff will not be able to do so, either for family or financial reasons. Valuable local knowledge will therefore be lost.”

“I am aware that the lease for the Clyde station comes to an end in 2012. That appears to be a major consideration in the reasoning behind the Government’s decision to close the station.”

“Real estate considerations should not be paramount. Safety should be the prime consideration and the fact that the lease is up for renewal should not be a major factor.”

“I hope that the Government will recognise the importance of the Clyde coastguard station and realise that they do not want to lose its staff’s experience and expertise. I hope that they will reflect on the consultation and will agree to keep the Clyde coastguard station open.”

Tuesday, 14 June 2011

Consultation on school closures stopped

Argyll and Bute Council has agreed to stop its consultation process on proposals to amalgamate 11 primary schools.

The decision was taken at the council meeting on June 14 where members agreed to stop the consultation process. The decision comes in light of advice, given by the cabinet secretary for education and lifelong learning, to the Scottish Parliament, on Thursday 9 June, that the current schools consultation legislation is “defective.”

The council did not agree to support the cabinet secretary’s request for a one-year moratorium on proposals to close rural schools. Instead councillors agreed the moratorium should be discussed with the Scottish Government by COSLA, on behalf of all councils. The council will also ask COSLA to investigate how the implementation of the legislation was carried out by the government and will ask it to consider the possibility of a judicial review.

Council leader Dick Walsh said:

“In light of the comments made by the education secretary to the Scottish Parliament, where he outlined his concerns with the Schools (Consultation) (Scotland) Act 2010, and described the Act as “defective” we feel it is right to stop our consultation process. It is not appropriate for the council to continue working under legislation which the education secretary himself believes to be flawed and not fit for purpose.

“We will work with COSLA to explore the wider implications of a moratorium and the impact it will have on education across Argyll and Bute.

“Our priority remains to provide all children in Argyll and Bute with a high standard of education. We welcome the news that the education secretary will examine the links between rural schools and the support and development of vibrant rural communities.

“We hope the education secretary will look at collaborative learning as part of his review and see how this can be applied successfully in very small, rural schools.

“Today’s decision to stop the current consultation process does not change the fact that in Argyll and Bute we have considerable surplus capacity in our primary schools. It does not change the fact that some of our schools have as few as three or four pupils, which makes it very difficult to successfully implement collaborative learning techniques such as Curriculum for Excellence. It does not change the fact that we have been advised for a number of years by audit and inspection bodies to review our school estate.

“We need to make sure our children and our teachers have access to education techniques which are recognised as best practice for today and tomorrow.”

The council also welcomed Mr Russell’s proposal to establish a commission to investigate the delivery of rural education and supports the view that Audit Scotland and HMIE should be part of the process.

Councillor Walsh continued:

“As Argyll and Bute Council has the most recent and most extensive experience of trying to work within the current legislation we feel representatives from the council should form part of the commission itself. Rural schools in dispersed communities make up a large proportion of Argyll and Bute’s education establishment. We have tried to work within the current legislation and have seen first hand the inconsistencies in its application. We are very keen to share this experience with the commission and help to refine the legislation.

“We specifically would like the scope of the commission to cover collaborative learning in small schools, a definitive model for defining school capacity and an absolute definition of educational benefit. It should also include guidelines to determine the sustainability of school buildings and equipment.

“Until we have these clear guidelines it is impossible for any new legislation to be applied fairly or consistently across all schools.”

The council agreed the decision to halt consultation would not apply to schools which have no pupils.

Hòro-gheallaidh le The Outside Track air an t-slighe gu Blas

Airson a’ chiad turas, bidh còmhla-ciùil fa-leth a’ riochdachadh fèis Blas 2011 fad na Fèise a thòisicheas air feadh na Gàidhealtachd air 9 Sultain.

Tha an còmhlan The Outside Track a’ cluich measgachadh de cheòl is òrain Albannach, à Canada agus an Eireann agus ri dannsa cuideachd agus tha iad air cliù a chosnadh air feadh an t-saoghail airson an làthaireachd. ‘S e meas air ceòl traidiseanta agus sannd a bhith ag ùrachadh agus a’ toirt air adhart stuth air a bhonntachadh air an dualchas a tha ceangal buill a’ chòmhlain, a bhoinneas do dh’Alba, Èireann, Ceap Breatann (le taobh ri Uidhist a Tuath) agus Vancouver. Bheir iad am blas is dreach fhèin air an fhèis agus bidh hòro-gheallaidh dha-rìreabh nan cois.

Tha còignear anns a’ chòmhlan: Mairi Rankin à Mabou ann an Ceap Breatann (ach a bhoinneas do dh’Uidhist a Tuath tro a màthair Oighrig, a chaidh a Chanada a theagasg na Gàidhlig) agus a tha a’ cluich anns an t-sàr-bhuidhinn Beòlach air an fhidhill, a’ seinn agus ri dannsa; a bhana-sheinneadair Norah Rendell a chaidh a chur air adhart ann am farpais Seinneadair Traidiseanta na Bliadhna ann an Canada air duiseal, fìdeag agus a’ seinn; Ailie Robertson a bha anns a’ chuairt dheireannach de dh’Fharpais Traidiseanta a’ BhBC airson Òigridh air a’ chlàrsaich agus a’ dannsa; Fiona Black, a bhuinnig farpais Fame Academy a’ BhBC air a’ bhocsa; agus Cillian Ó Dalaigh bho Trazz leguitar, a’ seinn agus a’ dannsa.
‘S e sàr-chluicheadairean fa-leth a th’anns gach ball dhen chòmhlan agus tha iad le chèile air grunn dhuaisean eadar-nàiseanta a thogail air an t-slighe gu Blas 2011. Ach ‘s ann còmhla a tha an luach as motha an-lùib leithid de bhuidhinn agus gan dèanamh cho tarraingeach. Tha iad air a bhith a’ cuairteachadh an t-saoghail a-nis airson 5 bliadhna eadar Breatann, an Roinn Eòrpa, Canada agus na Stàitean, a’ nochdadh aig cuid de na Fèisean Ciùil as motha air an t-saoghal eadar Celtic Colours, Goderich, Mission, Memoire et Racines, Sidmouth, agus Whitby.

Mar chòmhlan ainmichte na Fèise, chan eil teagamh aig Stiùiriche Blas Donna NicRath nach toir iad togail àraid do thachartasan anns gach àite. Thuirt i: “Tha sinn air leth toilichte còmhla cho cliùteach ri Outside Track a thoirt chun na Fèise airson a bhith againn fad na h-ùine. Chan eil an leithid ann ‘s dòcha mar chluicheadairean fa-leth, agus ‘s e gnothach eile a bhios ann èisteachd riutha mar chòmhlan nuair a bhios iad air ghleus againn fad naoi latha san t-Sultain.”

Bidh The Outside Track a’ nochdadh aig an fhèis air feadh na Gàidhealtachd bho Ulapul gu Port-Rìgh, Inbhir Garaidh, Baile a’ Chaolais, Port MoCholmaig agus Poll Iùbh. Bidh an còmhlan cuideachd a’ tadhal air sgoiltean air feadh na Gàidhealtachd mar phàirt de Phrògram Foghlaim Blas, air a cho-òrdnachadh le Oifigeach Ceanglan nan Ealan aig Comhairle na Gàidhealtachd, agus trom bi timcheall air 5,000 duine cloinne a’ faighinn cothrom gach bliadhna.

Tha The Outside Track gu bhith a’ cluich aig sreath de thachartasan èibheiseach far a bheil prìomh luchd-ealain nan tarraing aig cridhe fèis Blas 2011 a tha a’ luaidh cultar nan eilean. Tha Blas a-nis stèidhichte anns an 7mh bliadhna agus mar phrìomh fhèis a’ taisbeanadh subhachas is cultar na Gàidhlig air a’ Ghàidhealtachd.

REID BACKS CAMPAIGN AGAINST UNFAIR CHANGES TO WOMEN’S STATE PENSION AGE

Alan Reid is backing the campaign against Government plans which will see thousands of women waiting up to two years longer for their state pension.
In its current form the Pensions Bill brings forward equalisation of men’s and women’s State Pension Age to 2018, instead of 2020 as previously planned.
This means that 300,000 women born between December 1953 and October 1954 will have to work an additional 18 months or more. 33,000 will have to work an extra two years.
Alan Reid has supported a House of Commons motion to keep the equalisation date in 2020.
He told the House of Commons that the year of the equalisation of men’s and women’s state pension ages should stay at 2020.
Mr Reid told the House of Commons that women caught up by the change would have to work considerably longer before they could collect their pension, and are being given short notice to prepare for the extra work.
He concluded by asking the Government to go away and reflect on the matter before the Pensions Bill comes to the House of Commons.

FEED IN TARRIFF DECISION A BLOW TO RENEWABLE AIMS - says NFUS

NFU Scotland is deeply disappointed that the Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC) is to proceed with low level increases in the tariffs available to those looking to generate energy from anaerobic digestion. Failure to significantly increase the rates now threatens to stifle the potential that the technology offers to Scotland.

While energy generation from solar sources is less important to Scotland, the DECC has also announced significant cuts in the feed-in tariff (FiTs) rates for energy from this source making development of solar power increasingly difficult in the future.

The new rates of FiTs proposed for energy generated by new anaerobic digestion and solar projects are unchanged from those originally proposed by DECC in its March consultation. That means that the DECC opted to ignore a huge response from industry to its consultation, urging a more positive approach to these technologies. The FiTs rates announced by the DECC will be effective for new plants from August onwards.

NFU Scotland President, Nigel Miller said:

“The news that energy tariffs available to anaerobic digestion projects in the future will only see limited increases is a blow and leaves such planned developments at a competitive disadvantage compared to other renewable sources.

“Anaerobic digestion (AD) has the potential to produce real value and generate energy from waste products in a reliable manner, and could make a huge contribution to Scotland and the UK’s renewable targets if given the chance. By failing to come forward with realistic tariff rates for energy from AD, the DECC runs the risk of sidelining this technology.

“The digestate produced from AD can also contribute as a valuable soil nutrient. The integral pasteurisation of the AD process ensures high levels of safety which makes the digestate a potential substitute for expensive oil based fertilisers.

“By limiting the increase in the tariffs available to future AD projects, the DECC has hit at the core of the Zero Waste Scotland approach and shown limited ambition in growing our green credentials. When there was a genuine prospect of a significant number of new AD plants being established, those looking at on-farm AD will now have to go back and do their sums to see if the significant investment is justified.

“While our climate may limit our solar energy options, we are aware of some in Scotland who were seriously looking at this. Again, the DECC decision to cut tarriff rates for energy from this source will be a significant blow.”

MINISTERIAL STATEMENT ON RURAL SCHOOLS MICHAEL RUSSELL MSP, CABINET SECRETARY FOR EDUCATION AND LIFELONG LEARNING

CHECK AGAINST DELIVERY


I would like to thank the Parliament for the opportunity to make a
statement on my proposals to establish a Commission on the Delivery of
Rural Education and my request to local authorities for a moratorium on
rural school closures.

There are, in my experience, few issues which have united all sides of
this Parliament.

However, the Schools (Scotland) (Consultation) Bill, which the
Parliament agreed to unanimously in November 2009 did so.

Before this Parliament was established there were significant concerns
expressed from many quarters, over many years, about the procedures
local authorities had to follow in relation to school closures.

In particular, there was a feeling that schools were being closed
without proper and full consultation with the communities they served;
this resulted in much worry, anger and resentment for pupils, parents
and staff.

At the outset, Presiding Officer, let me make it clear that sometimes
schools have to close. Communities change, populations move, sometimes
buildings become unsuitable. But common decency as well as good
practice demands that a closure must command public confidence. The
process of decision making must be inclusive and transparent.

Ten years ago, in 2001, the Parliament's Education Committee looked into
the issue of school closures following consideration of a petition. One
of the outcomes was an invitation to COSLA to draw up new rules about
the school closures process. Unfortunately, this did not take place
and, as a consequence, little changed.

Schools continued to close, in ways which appeared to be based on little
joined up thinking regarding the impact closure would have on the wider
community and its economic and social future.

In 2007, in an attempt to address this, Murdo Fraser introduced his
private members Bill. While this was intended to relate to all school
closures, it nevertheless had a particular focus and concern about rural
schools and the importance of schools to the wider rural community.
This evolved into the "Safeguarding Our Rural Schools" consultation,
from which emerged our Bill.

The delivery of education in rural communities is about much more than
just a building. A school can, and often is, fundamental to the social
and economic make up of a village, township or area.

Therefore, at the core of any decisions about schools in rural
communities should lie a presumption against closure - a policy which
has existed in England for some time.

The legislation was intended to make the proposed closure of any school,
an open, transparent and fair one.

We sought to increase local participation, to create a genuine dialogue
between Councils and their communities and to foster a greater sense of
trust between local authorities and the people they serve - and this was
particularly important for rural areas.

So, we put in place a number of special provisions for such areas. In
the case of proposals to close a rural school, there are three factors
to which the council must have regard before moving to consult - these
are:

* Viable alternatives to closure must be considered;

* The likely effects of closure on the community as a
whole must be considered; and

* Any changed travelling arrangements for children must be
considered.

The result of this is to ensure that a decision to close a rural school
must be regarded as a decision of last resort.

In addition, prior to the Bill, the involvement of Ministers in a
closure decision had been mainly related to issues around occupancy and
distance.

The new Bill established a more formal role by means of a safeguard
whereby Ministers would be able to call in those decisions in which they
perceived serious flaws in the consultation or decision making process.
That call-in can also be triggered by community or parental request, but
such requests have to outline a flaw in process.

The key word here is process - the Bill was and is not about prejudging
or second guessing a local authority's decision but ensuring that the
process, as enshrined by statute, had been carried through properly and
correctly.

At the time of the Bill's passage in November 2009, most envisaged that
no more than a handful of cases would be called in. The Government had
confidence in a process the whole Chamber had endorsed.

However, it is clear to me now that for all our good work, there have
been widely differing interpretations of the Act by local authorities,
communities and central government. These differing interpretations are
hindering the clear policy intention of the Bill. Therefore they now
require some action.

For example, in the 12 months or so since the Act came into force (on 5
April 2010), Councils have proposed 35 school closures. This reflects,
to some extent, the financial pressures that Councils are currently
under.

However, the Bill made clear that the basis for closure decisions and
must be educational benefit. Closures driven by finance alone are not
permitted, yet councils still buttress their closure decisions with
financial rhetoric.

Of that 35, I have found it necessary to call in 17. So far, 4 have
been given unconditional consent to close, 4 have been allowed to close
subject to conditions and 4 have been refused - the remaining 5 are
still under consideration by me. There are also another 5 closure
proposals going through the process which will be presented for my
consideration shortly.

For all involved, this is proving to be an unsatisfactory process. We
all felt at the time that we were making an improvement to the law. But
that improvement has not led to the necessary changes on the ground, or
at least not everywhere.

Many more proposals for rural school closures are coming forward than
was envisaged.

The consultation process is not being followed in more cases than we
expected.

During the election, we made clear in our manifesto an intention to
strengthen the 2010 Act to ensure that consultation is genuine and based
on accurate information.

In addition, we also wanted to reinforce the existing presumption
against closure and find a revised means of supporting the delivery of
education in rural areas.

So, how should this be done?

Hopefully with thought, with care and with regard to all the relevant
issues - such as the impact on the community, parental wishes, the
welfare of children, joined up services and better education.

But Presiding Officer, this cannot be delivered against a backdrop of
conflict, confusion and discontent.

It is for all these reasons that last week I announced the setting up of
a Commission on the Delivery of Rural Education. It will be tasked
with, among other things:

* Reviewing the current legislation and its application;

* Making recommendations on how to reflect best practice
and fulfil our manifesto commitment;

* Examining the links between rural schools and the
preservation, support and development of rural communities;

* Looking at the funding issues surrounding rural schools
and the delivery of rural education; and

* Thinking new thoughts about the means of such delivery.

Most importantly, it will have licence to look ahead radically and
boldly. I will be expecting it to come forward with recommendations at
the start of next year.

I will announce the membership of the Commission and its full remit
shortly.

Clearly, input from a wide range of organisations and individuals will
be sought to help the Commission undertake its work. COSLA and ADES
will be essential participants.

To allow the Commission to undertake its work within a positive and
proper context I have also proposed a moratorium on rural school
closures. This will create the space necessary to allow a comprehensive
and fair assessment of the present school closures process and allow
clear thinking on how it can be improved.

This moratorium will run for a year. I believe it is in everyone's
interests to pause and take time to consider the best way forward.

Many councils have expressed concerns about how the present process of
proposed closures is working - so have parents, so have Members on all
sides of this Parliament. Therefore, I expect and hope for a positive
response from councils, from parents and from Members of this Parliament
to my proposals for a moratorium. I am pleased to say that a number of
councils have already indicated their support.

It is my aim that we work together across the various interests in order
to find a consensus and solve these problems which affect many parts of
Scotland. There is no future in simply digging-in to entrenched
positions.

Presiding Officer, I think we would all want to ensure that what
Parliament had in its mind when it agreed the Schools (Consultation)
(Scotland) Act 2010 can finally be applied in an effective and proper
way and that the need for educational benefit is the driving force and
the sole motivation behind each and every proposed school closure,
especially in vulnerable rural areas.

Presiding Officer, I believe that our rural communities are the fresh
air that energise much of Scottish society. I am very aware that the
closure of a rural school can unbalance and sometimes destroy a rural
community for ever.

This chamber has already agreed that action is needed to prevent that.
My new proposals re-enforce that agreement.

SNP call for common sense to prevail on School closure consultations

A special council meeting has been called by The Administration of Argyll and Bute Council for the 14th June, following a request by The Cabinet Secretary for Education, Michael Russell MSP, for a Scotland wide, year long, moratorium on school closures in order to review legislation. The present Council Administration formed by Conservative, Liberal Democrats and members of the Alliance of Independent Councillors have been progressing a controversial programme of school closure consultations.

Opposition groups on the council met today to discuss a joint approach to the special council meeting. Leader of the Opposition, SNP Councillor Robert MacIntyre, said following the meeting -

‘We had a very constructive meeting today with our opposition colleagues, we are encouraged that the Administration has decided to consider the request by Mr Russell, it is clear that the Administration is not fully committed to these closure consultations in the new political reality following the election of a majority SNP Government.

‘The Opposition is united in its support for the views expressed by our communities on the education of their children. I am sure this commitment will be carried forward into the 2012 Council elections. For our part, the SNP in Argyll & Bute are ready to work constructively with any elected member who will support the sustainability of rural life in Argyll and Bute of which rural schools play a major role. I hope this gives some security to our communities; the only consultation they need to secure their schools will be at the ballot box next May.’

The SNP Group left the ruling Administration of the Council last year when they could no longer support the proposals sponsored by the Alliance of Independent Councillors, proposals which they described at a heated council meeting on the 25th November 2010 as “fundamentally flawed.” Surprisingly, two staunch critics of the proposals at that time , Liberal Democrat Councillors Robin Currie and Rory Colville ensured that closure consultations continued by changing their opinion and vote so securing an enhanced wage for themselves when the Lib Dems and Conservatives replaced the SNP in Administration.

One unexpected outcome from the closure programme has been the formation of ARSN – Argyll Rural Schools Network who have been hyper-active and vocal at every council meeting, exploiting energy and imagination to raise the standard for rural communities.

At a Special Council meeting organised by the SNP on the 4th January, well attended by ARSN both internally and in the winter cold outside, the original proposals for consultation on closure of 25 schools were overturned. However, unperturbed, the new Liberal Democrat Education Spokesperson, Ellen Morton devised a new reduced list of 12 schools which are now going through the consultation process.

John Semple, SNP liaison Councillor with ARSN said –

‘From the very start of these consultations I have consistently highlighted the vitality and potential that lies latent in our rural communities, it is very sad that the Liberal Democrats, who used to portray themselves as champions of rural life in Scotland, have abandoned that principled stand.

‘it is clear from the activity of ARSN that rural Argyll and Bute is alive and very much kicking. I would call, once more, on the leader of the council not just to abandon these consultations but to commit to engaging constructively with rural communities to plan a sustainable future for rural life.’