Friday, 6 November 2009

Question Time - BBC ALBA

Jamie McGrigor (Highlands and Islands) (Con): To ask the Scottish Executive what representations it will make with regard to the BBC Trust's review of BBC Alba. (S3O-8339)

The Minister for Culture, External Affairs and the Constitution (Michael Russell): The Scottish Government will make it clear to the BBC Trust that we regard BBC Alba as a vital addition to Scottish broadcasting. From the very date of its launch, the Scottish Government has supported the availability of BBC Alba on Freeview—a matter that I have raised repeatedly with the BBC at every appropriate level.

Jamie McGrigor: The minister will be aware that the Scottish Conservatives have consistently argued that BBC Alba should be available on Freeview. Many of my constituents in the Highlands and Islands believe that the issue is one of fairness. Does the minister agree? Will he continue to make the strongest possible case for the availability of BBC Alba on Freeview, given the importance of the channel in sustaining and encouraging our Gaelic culture and heritage?

Michael Russell: Absolutely. Developing and maintaining a critical mass of viewers for BBC Alba requires it to be available on Freeview. There is some concern about some of the BBC Trust's arguments on the issue, which appear to have emerged out of nowhere. We will vigorously support the channel's availability on Freeview. Indeed, I have said on occasions, particularly to the Scottish member of the BBC Trust, that I cannot understand why the decision is taking a year. It should have been made much more quickly.

Rob Gibson (Highlands and Islands) (SNP): The minister mentioned the attitude of the BBC Trust. It has suggested that radio stations could be blocked out when BBC Alba is screened. Will the minister take up the case and ensure that the BBC Trust also considers the television channels that broadcast late at night and are not on at the same time as BBC Alba? Will he ask why the BBC Trust is targeting the radio stations, which are alternatives for our listeners and viewers?

Michael Russell: To be scrupulously fair to the BBC, which is something that I try to be, it has listed a number of options as possibilities, of which the removal of a number of radio services is only one. Many of us were surprised to discover that that was one of the options. There are better options. We will argue for the options that ensure that services continue to be provided but that an additional service is provided—BBC Alba.

European Commission closes investigation into public financing of ferry shipping services in Scotland

The European Commission has today decided that public financing for the operation of ferry shipping services in Scotland is compatible with State aid rules. However, this decision is subject to the condition that the national authorities launch a transparent and non-discriminatory public tender for the operation of the Gourock-Dunoon route in the western islands. The Commission will continue to closely monitor the public financing of the Scottish ferry transport system in order to avoid any undue distortion of competition.
On 16 April 2008, the Commission started1 an in-depth review of the public financing of regular ferry shipping services between the Scottish mainland and the islands off the west and north coasts of Scotland. With the exception of the Gourock-Dunoon route in the western islands, these services are currently provided under public service contracts, which followed open public tender procedures. The operators currently providing these services are: CalMac Ferries Ltd. (western islands, with the exception of Gourock-Dunoon); Cowal Ferries Ltd. (Gourock-Dunoon route); and NorthLink Ferries Ltd. (northern islands).
In its decision of April 2008, the Commission expressed doubts about whether the public compensation granted to the operators of the different routes was proportional to its declared objective. In particular, the Commission wanted to ascertain whether the compensation paid to the operators did not exceed the costs of providing the public service entrusted on them and whether these operators had engaged in any type of anti-competitive behaviour. In the absence of a public tender for the operation of the Gourock-Dunoon route, the Commission also doubted whether the public compensation for the operation of this route was compatible with State aid rules. In today's decision, the Commission confirmed that the public service obligations for the western and northern islands were legitimately defined and entrusted on the operators, with the exception of the Gourock-Dunoon route. In the case of this route, the national authorities have committed to take the necessary steps to launch a public tender for its operation before the end of 2009. The subsequent public service contract should enter into force before end June 2011.

Thursday, 5 November 2009

McGrigor Speech on National Parks

Jamie McGrigor MSP (Con) gave the following speech to the Scottish Parliament in a debate on National Parks:


I am very pleased to be able to take part in today’s debate. National Parks obviously play a large part in the life of my Highlands & Islands region through our two national parks in the Cairngorms Loch Lomond & the Trossachs.

I agree with the broad thrust of the recommendations of the National Park Review including the plans to reduce the number of members on the National Park Authorities’ Boards. One concern that I have to say has been put to me as an MSP over the years has been that some elements of the administration of the parks have been overly bureaucratic and anything that streamlines their operation and increases efficiency is to be welcomed. One constituent suggested to me that staff turnover in the Loch Lomond & Trossachs National Park is also an issue of concern.

I believe strongly that the future of rural Scotland- including our National Parks- depends not just on preserving our environment and sustaining existing communities and livelihoods but in allowing and indeed encouraging new development – of both businesses and housing- and the appropriate, sustainable usage of our natural resources. Some of my constituents remain concerned that our National Parks have sadly stifled development which would otherwise have been given the go-ahead and which would have boosted local economies.

As Communities & Housing Spokesman, the provision of affordable rural housing is an issue very close to my heart. One issue of concern that has been raised with me by constituents in the area of the Cairngorms National Park- and which I have spoken about in a previous debate- is the requirement on developers by the CNPA that up to 50% of new homes in a development have to be affordable. While of course we all share the aim to see more affordable housing in the National Park area, it has been put to me that this restriction is deterring developers from building at all in the National Park area and that perhaps the area is therefore missing the option of any affordable houses being built. It is basically doubling a tax which at best many see as an already inefficient method of producing affordable housing.

Constituents in the Cairngorms National Park have asked me to raise a further specific development issue, namely the proposed new community of An Camas Mòr. Outline permission was applied for in May and the applicants naturally would like a timely decision so that they might be able to start on the detail work next year. The time it takes to get planning decisions is an important issue.

The innovative An Camas Mòr masterplan is a community vision which goes back to the proposal of the Community Council in 1989 when Aviemore's affordable housing shortage problem was being discussed. It is interesting to note that housing was seen as a problem 20 years ago and since then too little has been done to improve the situation. I believe this vision has very exciting possibilities for the future.

To those who are against this type of development in the National Park, I would only say that considering the enormous size of the Cairngorm National Park, it is vital that there are sustainable and vibrant communities within the boundaries in order to ensure a nucleus for productive activity and job creation. Environmentally sound and attractive developments where people can make their homes will be infinitely superior to a situation of continued housing shortages which lead to a stifling of objectives. A development of this kind obviously offers huge opportunities for local companies and many extra jobs.

I also want to touch on some of the very good work that has taken place in our National Parks. I remain particularly interested in the work the CPNA is doing in offering training to land based businesses in the Cairngorms National Park area. This training is benefiting estates, farms, crofts, forestry, fishing, horticulture, nurseries and outdoor recreation providers in the CPNA, indeed any business that is related to the management or use of the land. Environmental courses such as deer stalking certificates, black grouse management, mole control, water margin management and dry stone wall dyking are vital in maintaining traditional skills.

Public benefit courses that have been delivered through the training programme include ones on the Scottish Outdoor Access Code, Cairngorms Wildlife, Tick Control- a subject which is hugely important both health-wise and economically-& Heather Management and Catering for the Less-able Visitor. The comments received from businesses and organisations within the CNPA about the training have been positive.

In the Loch Lomond & The Trossachs National Park a community training programme runs courses in a range of subjects including how community organisations can better access funding streams. I am also impressed by the work that Loch Lomond & The Trossachs National Park Authority is doing to increase apprenticeships in the area of the park and to encourage businesses in the park to make use of the latest IT technology. I was also pleased to see the Park encouraging barn owls with some success.

Today’s debate is welcome and useful. I wish the Minister’s National Parks Strategy group success and hope that any further sensible recommendations can be implemented quickly in the interests of my constituents and Scotland as a whole.

Roadside signage - COMPELLING CASE TO UNITE IN THE INTEREST OF LOCAL ECONOMIC RECOVERY - MATHER

Jim Mather, MSP, for Argyll & Bute, has expressed the hope that planning
officials at Argyll & Bute Council can reach a pragmatic new
understanding regarding roadside advertising by small businesses across
the Oban and Lorn area. Several businesses have contacted him directly
about this, voicing concern about the threat to such business-critical
signage; particularly as some of them are under threat of summary
action by the council.

Jim Mather said,

"I am disappointed that the enforcement action on signage against
businesses is taking place without a more constructive debate as to how
we can boost local business; particularly when so many are already
under pressure to survive in the present difficult economic climate.

Therefore, I will be taking this matter up with senior council officials
to see why this action is being undertaken at this time and what we all
might do to progress matters and get results that everyone needs.

We have been fortunate this year to have enjoyed a successful tourist
season when all the early indicators were that we might suffer.

Under the new Planning Act the local authority has greater enforcement
powers but they also have responsibilities and I trust that they will
help more and more local businesses, provide services for locals and for
visitors and contribute to the well being of the whole community.

Where signage is intrusive or dangerous to road users there clearly
needs to be action taken but information about services must be
available to visitors, particularly where facilities are off the main
road, and a pragmatic approach is called for. The new charter that the
Council are supposed to operate under indicates that, 'a flexible and
pro-active approach towards enforcement, where possible dealing with
breaches by means of retrospective planning applications' and that
'enforcement is a discretionary power and that the Council is not bound
to act where there is a wider public interest.'

These guidelines are already in place and I feel confident that,
properly applied, they can ensure that we can achieve outcomes that
encourage small businesses and helps create a quality environment that
benefits locals, visitors, businesses and planners."

COUNCIL SEEKS INPUT ON FUTURE DEVELOPMENT OPTIONS

Argyll and Bute Council has launched a consultation exercise to seek the views of all interested parties on how the area might be developed in the future.

Developers and landowners are being asked to identify potential development sites, and members of the public, community groups and all other interested parties are being asked what they believe are the most important planning issues in their areas, and how best those might be addressed.

The move comes as part of the preparation of a new Local Development Plan (LDP).

The LDP will set out policies and proposals for the use of land and property within Argyll and Bute.

It will influence housing, shopping, business, industry, transport and the built and natural heritage, and will aim to guide future development to the most appropriate locations.

Anyone who wishes to promote a potential development site for possible inclusion in the LDP is being invited to submit details.

Sites submitted for consideration will not be automatically included in the Local Development Plan, but will be assessed against appropriate technical information and subject to widespread engagement with communities and consultation with key parties over the months ahead.

In addition, the Council is inviting individuals and groups to comment on what they see as the key planning issues affecting their areas, and how they think the previous adopted local plan has performed.

The feedback from this consultation exercise will also be used in developing a land-use map and in developing policy options for the finalised Plan.

To help facilitate this process, two questionnaires have been produced and are now available on the Council’s website (www.argyll-bute.gov.uk/) to download.

Both forms are also available at Kilmory, Lochgilphead, PA31 8RT (Telephone: 01546 4140) and can also be picked up at the area planning offices in Ardrishaig, Oban, Blairvadach, Helensburgh and Dunoon.

The three-month consultation period closes on 31 January 2010. Submissions should be returned, preferably by e mail, to ldp@argyll-bute.gov.ukor the above postal address.

Wednesday, 4 November 2009

TECHNICAL EVALUATION OF PORT ASKAIG RECENT FERRY BERTH DEVELOPMENTS.

Information provided by
Donald Ewen Darroch
Chairperson
Islay & Jura Ferry Co Ltd
Inver Lodge
Isle of Jura


1. Standards.
The following British Standards, Lloyds Rules and Reports on Ro Ro Berths are in general use to help designers and contractors involved in the development of Ro Ro Ferry berths. They give a minimum requirement but are not comprehensive allowing any designs to be developed to best suit the circumstances.
BS. 6347. Maritime Structures. Part 1 General 2
Part 2 Quay walls and Dolphins
Part 4 Fendering
Part 8 Linkspans
Lloyds Register Rules and Regulations for Linkspans
CIRIA report on Linkspans and their safety.
LR and BS both refer to other of their Rules and Standards which should be used in conjunction with these e.g. BS 5400 Bridge Code and Ship’s Rules.
Certain information must be supplied by the client ( in this case Argyll & Bute Council ) with regards to depth of water, tidal levels and currents, exposure and wave climate and the type of vessels that are expected now and in the future to use the berths.

2. Types of Berths.
In Scottish waters with significant tidal ranges two types of RoRo berths are in use.
Type 1.The slipway, which developed as a result of the arrival of the mv “Isle of Gigha” on the West Coast in 1960’s. It was one of the first Ro Ro ferries and did not initially run on a regular route. It landed vehicles on beaches and existing stone slipways. Many of which were available and built in the 19th century under the “Congested Districts” Act or on drove routes. Vessels berthed alongside the slipway at a position appropriate for the tide level.
Calmac copied this type of vessel in their Island Class and the Western Councils built new slipways. Calmac now have 16 smaller vessels using this method and the Councils operate some ferries in a similar way. Council slipways are expensive to build because of a high proportion of tidal and underwater work in their construction. The hull form required by the vessels to use these slipways is inefficient. The transition angles between ship’s deck/ramp/slipway are often too severe and car damage occurs. Unless slipways are in well sheltered positions bow loading vessels are vulnerable to pounding and service reliability is impaired as a result.


Type 2a. Ship supported Linkspans. Orkney and Shetland County Councils led by Western Ferries followed the well established Scandinavian practice using simple linkspans supported at the outer end by the vessel during loading. Dolphins provide a berthing face for vessels. The small island ferries as well as those the size of Calmac mainline vessels, all use this type of Linkspan. There are a total of 20 vessels in Scottish waters using over 30 of this type of Linkspan. Many hundreds more use this system in Scandinavia, Holland and the Baltic. This system is also used for train ferries.

Type 2b. Mechanically Supported Linkspans. Calmac has 9 vessels which use Linkspans but they carry their own ramps even though they are open deck ships. They also have two closed deck vessels which are too large to use Port Askaig. The linkspan required for these ramped vessels is hinged on the shore above High Water mark and is supported at its outer end by a gantry with a mechanism that can adjust the outer end height under full load to suit the vessel using it.
The ship’s ramp bridges across from the car deck to the end of the Linkspan. Any movement due to swell, waves and the transit of heavy vehicles must the taken up by this short ramp. Its length limits the amount of vertical movement if vehicles are not to ground. This is made worse by the general exposure of the berths in Western Scotland which do not generally have closed sheltered ferry harbours.
The weight of these ships’ ramps, their supporting structure and mechanism reduce the carrying capacity of the vessel by about the equivalent of one commercial vehicle so reducing their earning capacity by between 15% and 40% for trucks. This additional weight, which is carried on each voyage, adds to the ship’s fuel consumption.

3. Vessels using this Port Askaig, Main berth
Calmac (presently ramped ships) currently have only 9 vessels that ought to be able to use this berth. Their beam ranges from 15.3m to 15.8m. Their freeboard varies between about 1.5m and 2.5m. These ships have ramps about 3.5m clear width, at bow and stern, centred on the centreline of the vessel. Ships of up to 16 meters beam might be expected in the future. These dimensions are breadth moulded and one should add 600mm for belting.
The maximum displacement of vessels is about 3,000 tonnes, on a draft of max 3.0m
Other Vessels (Probably non ramped ships) a private operator might use a similar but larger version of the “Sound of Jura” which operated successfully for 10 years on this route. This falls within the above parameters. Consideration should also be given to a Catamaran type of vessel such as the one under trial on the Pentland crossing. This vessel has a greater beam and freeboard than conventional singled hull ships and can be made to accept an off centre-line Linkspan.

PORT ASKAIG NEW DUAL BERTH
These observations result from an inspection of the berth on two occasions in autumn 2009 during periods of Spring Tides. No dimensions were taken, so they may vary from those stated.
A. BERTHING FACE. The Berthing face is fendered at even spacing using V fender elements faced with UHMWPE. The outer round head has closer spaced fenders and adequately fendered. This is in line with normal practice for facing to a sheet piled quay wall. Mooring arrangements are to conventional bollards with ships’ lines. There are adequate, well positioned bollards. The gangway is man handled at a fixed position. The mooring of the vessel requires 3 men at each end of the vessel, one on the gangway plus there are 3 men on the shore, 10 in total. A modern Ferry berth should not require such a high level of manning for the mooring and unmooring of vessels. No allowance appears to have been made for any type of auto mooring.
B.LINKSPAN. The linkspan is the bridge hinged on the inshore end and supported at the outer end on each side by a single hydraulic cylinder suspended from a gantry. It was designed and supplied by Macgregor as subcontractor to the main civil works contractor. It falls short of what should have been supplied in a number of ways.

1. The linkspan does not appear to be able to accept impact from the vessels using it. The BS and LR rules require that the linkspan should be able to absorb the impact of the maximum displacement vessel likely to use the berth at a speed of 0.35 m per sec. Furthermore it should accept in an emergency up to 0.5 m/sec without being put out of order and sustaining only local damage at point of impact. The CIRIA report shows that ship impact is one of the two most common reported incidents in Linkspans.

2. The centre Line of the Linkspan. The beam of the vessels varies very little from 15.3 to15.8 and a possible 16 in future. The centre line of the Linkspan should therefore be 7.8m (+0.3 for belting) from the line of the berthing face. It is far from this, having its quayside edge almost in line with the berthing face. The active roadway for the vessels using the linkspan needs only to extend from 5.15m to 9.75m from the berthing giving an outer width of 4.60m. To allow for two lane access which ought to apply on this route the outer end should extend to seaward by 3.5m making the outer end approximately 8.1m. The actual outer end is considerably wider than this but is so off centre that 30% of the Bridge will never be used. 7.35m is considered 2 lanes within the codes any greater must be treated as 3 lanes.
The consequences of this unnecessary width are:
a. 3 lanes must be used for calculation of traffic loads unnecessarily so increasing the cost of the steelwork and support mechanism.
b. A 5 m wide strip of Linkspan adjacent to the quay that can never be used.
c. Much higher loading on the outer support cylinder due to eccentric loading on the support mechanism.
The extra steel used in the ineffective quayside of the bridge would have been better used in increasing its length. (See below)

3. Length. The roadway at the hinge should be at least 500mm above HAT (+2.4CD) but greater than this if there is either a risk of being overtopped with waves or a tidal surge. The present level is probably at +2.9CD but should be +3.2CD. Both these circumstances occur at Port Askaig as the whole concrete apron that forms the hinge for the main berth and the slipway for the Jura Ferry has already been flooded to a depth of 300mm. At HAT +2.4CD with the ship’s deck (at its threshold of the ramp) 2.5m above the water level the level of the deck is +4.9CD. This is a rise from 2.9CD to 4.9CD. i.e. 2 meters requiring a minimum length of the Linkspan of 20m. It was not measured but it appears a lot less. At LAT for the Calmac ship there is a small downward gradient of 400mm and the length is OK. However due to incorrect levels at the Jura ferry slip this vessel must use the mainline berth. In this case the ship’s deck would be at +1.0CD at LAT with a rise of 1.9m requiring a length of 19m.
There are relatively simple solutions to these problems.

4. Landing Area on the Linkspan. The codes and rules recommend a shaped profile on the deck of the outer end of Linkspan where the ship’s ramp lands. This allows the ramp to land with a safe overlap of 1.5m and to present, if necessary, an upward gradient to the Linkspan. This is especially important at lowest tides. At high water the ship’s can ramp can present down to the Linkspan so avoiding critical humps and hollows and short lengths of extreme gradients as well as the ship’s ramp tripping.
It was observed that at least one commercial articulated truck could not cross the threshold on the ship’s flap area at high water. After a number of failed attempts with wheels spinning and running backwards, the vehicle had to roll backwards onto the concrete apron and then get up speed to charge over the hump, followed by hard braking to avoid hitting the vehicles already on the deck. The driver was no novice and told me it was a frequent problem.
Such dangerous practice is avoided if the design incorporates a profiled landing area and its shape is optimised for use by the regular ferry ramp. A curved profile is the most versatile.

5. Transition Angles. The codes clearly specify an acceptable change on angle at the interfaces at the hinge end of the Linkspan as well as at its landing area. The incident above shows how the Linkspan fails at its outer end. Even at the hinge end, fully under the control of the Linkspan designer, no transition flaps are included and yet the change of gradient from level to 1:10 is critical for many vehicles and 1:8 at extremes even more severe.

6. Support Mechanism. The BS 6347 Part 8 calls for redundancy in the support mechanism of a mechanically operated Linkspan. In the event of either cylinder or its connecting pins failing there must be another duplicate system to prevent collapse. Pairs of Cylinders on each side are the normal solution to this, each independently mounted, but there is a proprietary brake system being prototyped. There appears to be no such redundancy built into this Linkspan. CIRIA cites mechanical failure of the support system as the other of the main cause of reported incidents.
There are other support systems which have natural redundancy and fail safe that could have been considered.


C. JURA FERRY BERTH.
1. Berthing Face. The former open structure used by the original “Sound of Gigha” has been replaced by a sheet pile wall. The original open “Fence” was designed as a wave screen and allowed waves to be dissipated as they passed through it. With the solid wall, reflected waves create a “jabble” under relatively light conditions and cause the Jura Ferry to roll excessively. Floating fenders are necessary to reduce damage but they cannot be a permanent solution.
This problem would have been eliminated if the double sheet pile wall had been topped off at low water level and the last 3m made up of precast COBS (1mx1mx1m) which are hollow blocks used to face breakwaters. The small boats on the inside would have been less subjected to overtopping spray filling them in bad weather, and the Jura ferry would be able to lie at the berth as the wave climate would be substantially reduced. Without the floating fenders the “Eilean Dhiura” would be able to berth 1m to the south.

2. Slip. The stub ended slip worked satisfactorily with the old “Sound of Gigha” but less so with the new “Eilean Dhiura”. This type of slip in tidal ranges of 2 meters can be very satisfactory, cheap and better able to cope with bad weather as the bow is well clear of the ground. If the tidal rise is over 2m it is limited at extreme water levels. This could be solved by making two adjacent slips one with the landing point where the ship’s ramp lands 1 meter higher than the other. Performance will also be enhanced if the slip is curved in profile so that at highest tides the transition angles can be improved by increasing the overlap. At the moment the “Eilean Dhiura” lies in the mainline berth and has to use its own berth with a very poor Ramp/Linkspan interface when the mainland ferry is present.

D.TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT. The regulations require that foot passengers are physically separated from vehicular traffic. Sight Lines for drivers are also important as is good signage.
The car marshalling area is excellent considering the topography. Sight Lines from the Calmac ship’s are poor and vehicles must turn immediately on exiting the vessel. If the road had been widened to seaward in front of the slipway by the hotel, the approach line to the ship would have been much improved and safer. Only a meter or two would have made a great difference.
It is inevitable that there will be crossing traffic and pedestrians in this area. The raised pavement between shop and terminal acts as a speed bump but there are no other measures. This speed bump also slows the loading procedure for the ship. There is no actual control of passengers once they are on land, nor is there anything to stop local traffic moving across the ferry traffic.
During the 6-8 minutes that the vessel is discharging, a simple traffic light system stopping all traffic in the marshalling area and local traffic bound for the Hotel or shop would greatly reduce the risk of accident. The lights would allow pedestrians to cross between terminal and shop during this period. It would also show GO for the ferry traffic and give it a clear run out of Port Askaig. To start loading the ship, the pedestrian crossing would be at RED and all local traffic held from passing through boarding traffic. Such signal sequences could be controlled by the harbour master and would reduce risk to pedestrians.

CONCLUSION.
A successful Ferry Berth requires a careful liaison between: The client in this case Argyll & Bute Council, the appointed consulting Engineer who must be experienced not only in Marine works but in SHIPFIT*. The regular ship operators should of course be consulted and indeed asked to sign off the design where it will be effected, namely, mooring points, gangways, services, Linkspan interfaces and passenger and car control.
It is quite obvious that A&B Council were let down by their consultant whose design and specification fell short in these vital areas. Calmac have a history of changing ship’s and expecting new terminals to be built for them, but with experienced foresight and little extra cost, terminals built in the 70s and 80’s should be able to accommodate current vessels. There are many precedents of this. Other ships of the type and size for this route should be taken into account, (there are not many of them), otherwise taxpayers money is being used to bolster a monopoly. Indeed we would hope that A&B Council have not allowed themselves to be in such a position, that a challenge could make them vulnerable to EU demanding their funds back if the terminals could be shown to be sustaining – favouring a monopoly and precluding the use of terminals by others.
Another reason for this poor interface is that the contractors have no experience of understanding of SHIPFIT so that when they are preparing their tender they ask for a price from a Linkspan supplier. The main contractor is only interested in the lowest price and will not submit a better alternative even it is a penny more. Indeed if this “penny more” better linkspan saves thousands in Civil Works it is the last thing that the main Contractor wants to know as it reduces his work and therefore profit.
Not one of the parties alone can be blamed for these faults but the arrangements for designing, specifying, tendering and implementation used create these results. Most independent and many local authority ports adopt a different approach with better results.
The recent record of construction of Ro Ro berths in Argyll does not look well when one considers the number of rebuilds, major modifications and unused berths that result in lack of foresight and understanding of marine matters. Perhaps within the public sphere there is another organisation who would be better placed to manage the Argyll piers and harbours than the present incumbents?



*SHIPFIT : Is a recent term to describe the interface between the ship and the quay. It is rather specialised in RoRo operations and requires extensive and detailed knowledge of the bow and stern openings of Ferries and Ro Ro Ships.

PAYMENTS MUST BE LINKED TO PRODUCTIVITY SAYS NFUS

Future single farm payment (SFP) entitlements must recognise the productive potential of the land to which they accrue. Payments must also reflect the public goods being delivered as a result of agricultural activity as part of a system of rolling, activity- driven support according to NFU Scotland.

The Union’s view has been expressed in its submission to the Scottish Government’s Inquiry into Future Support for Agriculture in Scotland, chaired by Brian Pack. The Union is about to embark on a series of nationwide meetings* to discuss future options with its members and has submitted its initial views in the meantime.

NFUS’s ideal scenario is an operating environment from which farm businesses can secure sufficient, stable returns from the market place without requiring a separate system of public expenditure through the CAP in order for businesses to be viable.

However, in the absence of that operating environment, NFUS firmly believes that some form of direct support will be vital to keep farm businesses going. This can be justified on the basis of paying for the range of “non market” environmental, social and food security benefits that flow from agricultural activity.

NFU Scotland President, Jim McLaren said:

“A new set of SFP rules will be put in place by Europe in 2013, for implementation in 2014. The future single farm payment scheme must sustain the capacity for quality agricultural production, and in so doing secure the public benefits that flow.”

“We believe that the debate over when to change our SFP regime must be informed by the process of defining the right regime in Scotland. We have two headline objectives. Firstly, to recognise the productive capacity of, and public good delivery from, land. Secondly, to secure a system of rolling, activity-driven support. We don’t believe that an appropriate scheme to meet those objectives can be devised under the current rules. So we need to think about how we push for changes in the rules in the run-up to 2013.”

“NFUS has considered a number of models for the future SFP and believes that work must be done to evaluate these models and the impact that each one would have on individual farm businesses and Scotland’s ability to maintain agricultural capacity. Scotland should then use the time available to influence the United Kingdom authorities and the European Union so that the rules that come out of the negotiations in 2013 permit us to operate a scheme that will maintain capacity for quality agricultural production.”

“The SRDP could be used to assist farm businesses to take informed decisions in order to adapt agricultural practices to support the Scottish Government’s targets on climate change at the same time as delivering a range of wider rural development benefits as a consequence.”